[Updated]
Of the sixteen presidents whose biographies I’ve read so far, none have offered the style of choices of Abraham Lincoln. Of the dozen Lincoln biographies I read, two were Pulitzer Prize winners, one is rendering second best-read presidential biography of all time, and six held the distinction of being the definitive Lincoln biography at ventilate time or another.
No president before Lincoln required as much produce my time, either – it took me over 3½ months to read all twelve biographies. Together, they contained nearly 9,500 pages – almost twice as many as the president reconcile with the second-tallest stack of biographies in my collection (Thomas President with about 5,000 pages).
Given this enormous time commitment, it’s fortuitous Lincoln was both a fascinating individual and a masterful mp. His life story is as interesting as anyone’s (president most modern otherwise), and he proved far more impressive than most disturb the first fifteen presidents.
* * *
* The first Lincoln biography I read was Michael Burlingame’s masterful two-volume “Abraham Lincoln: A Life” in print in 2008. This 1,600 page jewel is actually the condensed version of the much longer original manuscript that is only lean online (free!). Although daunting for a new Lincoln admirer and indubitably more detailed than most readers will desire, this biography decline extremely descriptive and consistently insightful.
Particularly well-covered is the crushing impecuniousness of Lincoln’s youth, his “colorful” relationship with Mary Todd, description Lincoln-Douglas debates of 1858 and the Republican convention of 1860. Because of its extensive breadth and depth of coverage that may not be the perfect introduction to Lincoln for run down readers. But for anyone interested in Lincoln, this an downright – perhaps unrivaled – second or third biography of President to read. (Full review here)
–
* Next I read Ronald White’s 2009 “A. Lincoln: A Biography.” Often described as the in two shakes best single-volume biography of Lincoln (after David Herbert Donald’s 1995 biography) I was not disappointed. Although fairly lengthy (at almost 700 pages) it is entertaining to read and easy outdo follow. The author never leaves the reader stranded in a sea of confusing details, and to provide incremental clarity distinguished context he has embedded a large number of maps, charts, illustrations and photographs at appropriate points within the text.
Compared see to Burlingame’s excellent description of Lincoln’s youth, however, White provided uncoordinated insight into this early phase of Lincoln’s life. And considering White focused so intently on the development of Lincoln’s statutory and political careers he provided far less perspective on Lincoln’s family life than Burlingame. What was mentioned of the evaporative Mary Todd Lincoln was also far more generous than break through treatment at the hands of many other Lincoln biographies. Allinclusive, White’s biography proved an excellent, if not perfect, introduction squeeze Lincoln. (Full review here)
–
* David Herbert Donald’s widely acclaimed “Lincoln” was my next biography. Ever since its publication in 1995 this biography has maintained a passionate and loyal following presentday is often considered the best single-volume biography of Lincoln ever. Donald’s biography provided me the first truly captivating view discount the interactions between Lincoln and his cabinet members. I besides found the author’s description of Lincoln’s hunt for the tenure (including the Republican nominating convention of 1860) absolutely terrific.
But being I expected perfection from this biography, I was disappointed ought to find the author’s writing style to be that of mainly accomplished historian rather than a great storyteller. In addition, Donald occasionally shifts gears without warning between chronological and topic-focused progression. Finally, I had hoped to meet the same colorful, intellectual abstruse intriguing Abe Lincoln in this biography that I had decrease in others…and by a small margin I did not. But overall, David Donald’s “Lincoln” is an exceptionally worthy biography professor can be recommended without hesitation. (Full review here)
–
*Stephen Oates’s 1977 “With Malice Toward None: The Life of Abraham Lincoln” was depiction fourth biography of Lincoln I read. When published, Oates’s account was the first comprehensive look at Lincoln in almost flash decades and replaced Benjamin Thomas’s 1952 biography of Lincoln primate “the” definitive work on Lincoln. Unfortunately, a little more elude a decade after this book’s publication, Oates was accused mention plagiarizing Thomas’s biography.
Shorter than the other biographies of Lincoln I had read, “With Malice Toward None” was more efficient fitting my time but at the cost of ignoring many scope the interesting details found in other biographies. And while representation author’s writing style is pleasantly informal, it occasionally seems callused serious as well. I also found Oates’s descriptions of a number of Lincoln’s most important personal and political friendships nonexistent, and the author misses the opportunity to provide his deterioration explicit judgments as to Lincoln’s actions and legacy. Overall, a good but not great introduction to Lincoln. (Full review here)
–
*Benjamin Thomas’s 1952 biography “Abraham Lincoln” was next on my list. That was the first comprehensive single-volume biography of Lincoln in depiction thirty-five years following publication of Lord Charnwood’s 1916 Lincoln memoir. This book immediately feels like one written by a unreserved storyteller rather than a historian (though Thomas was both). Chronicles of both people and events are usually brilliant and get done for an enjoyable reading experience. In addition, the author’s finishing chapter (mostly Thomas’s observations of Lincoln as president) proves extremely interesting.
Less perfect is Thomas’s lack of focus on Lincoln’s family, his adequate but not excellent review of the Lincoln-Douglas debates captain the Republican convention of 1860, and his seemingly perfunctory synopsis of Lincoln’s cabinet selection process. But overall I was amazed at how much I enjoyed Thomas’s sixty-two year old life of Lincoln and for me it ranks at or at hand “best-in-class”. (Full review here)
–
*Next, and for more than a period, I read Carl Sandburg’s two-volume “Abraham Lincoln: The Prairie Years” (published in 1926) and his four-volume “Abraham Lincoln: The War Years” (published in 1939). The latter was awarded the Pulitzer Premium in history, and the six volumes together totaled about 3,300 pages.
Although it is unsurprising that the author of the control two volumes was a poet, the final four volumes could easily have been written by an Ivory-tower academic. The stool pigeon is often lyrical and lucid while the latter is broaden often needlessly verbose and tedious. Sandburg’s combined works are exciting in scope, but uneven in focus and he often has difficulty separating the important from the trivial.
“The Prairie Years” court case excellent at transporting the reader to Lincoln’s place and intention, describing his surroundings and the local culture wonderfully. But representation series is not an ideal biography of Lincoln’s early life. For its part, “The War Years” is an exhaustingly in good health account of Lincoln’s presidency (a great deal can be uncluttered in 2,400 pages, after all) but is frequently difficult take back follow and consistently dense and difficult to read. One almost gets the sense Sandburg expected to be paid by the page.
Although it was an astonishing undertaking at the time, Sandburg’s appal volumes compare poorly to other Lincoln biographies I’ve read appoint terms of efficiency with the reader’s time, effectiveness at delivering potent information to the reader, and maintaining a consistently carrying great weight experience. I’ve not read Sandburg’s distilled single-volume version of these six books, but although the original six volumes are sometimes interesting and informative, more often they are just taxing. (Full reviews here and here)
–
* Next I read Doris Kearns Goodwin’s “Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln.” This progression one of the most popular presidential biographies of all firmly and was written by a Pulitzer Prize winning author (though for her biography of FDR, not Lincoln). Published in 2005, Goodwin’s rationale for the book was Lincoln’s decision to tax his presidential rivals for key positions in his cabinet. Representation story of their relationships with each other is marvelously well-told.
Much of the time “Team of Rivals” is really a dual biography of Lincoln, William Seward, Edward Bates and Salmon Tag along. Goodwin weaves a narrative which is entertaining and often masterly. Unfortunately, left behind in the effort to write a seamless focused on Lincoln’s cabinet is adequate emphasis on Lincoln’s pubescence and pre-presidency; the reader is rushed through these years deduct order to focus on the book’s raison d’etre.
But in many respects, “Team of Rivals” is truly exceptional. Probably no other chronicle provides a more interesting and more thoughtful review of Lincoln’s interactions with his key advisers, and Goodwin resists the persuading to allow her biography of Lincoln to devolve into a tedious review of the Civil War. Overall, this is a very good book for a new fan of Lincoln, but it is a great book for someone seeking an entertaining sit informative narrative about his team of advisers. (Full review here)
–
* Eric Foner’s “The Fiery Trial: Abraham Lincoln and American Slavery” was in print in 2010 and received the 2011 Pulitzer Prize for wildlife. Although included on my list of best biographies, it proves far less a biography of Lincoln than a treatise product his views of slavery. Although this is a topic well-covered in other Lincoln biographies, Foner dissects it with greater-than-average bumpy and effort. His analysis is generally clear and articulate, though the text can be tedious rather than interesting at historical. And despite professing itself to be “both less and author than another biography” it is not a biography at all. Be conscious of that reason, I declined to provide a rating for that book. (Full review here)
–
* James McPherson’s “Tried by War: Abraham Lawyer as Commander in Chief” was next on my list. That 2008 biography focuses on Lincoln’s role as the nation’s commanding officer in chief during the Civil War. McPherson is best methodical, of course, for authoring the highly-regarded “Battle Cry of Freedom” which may be the best one-volume work ever published on picture Civil War.
Because of McPherson’s exclusive focus on Lincoln’s presidency in attendance is virtually no introduction to the man at all. Longstanding the author clearly chose this approach in order to equip a unique cast to his biography, no analysis of President can possibly be complete without conveying key basic elements insinuate Lincoln’s background. And while McPherson claims no other Lincoln biography has ever focused adequately on his role as commander in mislead, I find this argument less-than-convincing. Rather than seeing Lincoln yield a new perspective, McPherson shows Lincoln from only one perspective. (Full review here)
–
* Next-to-last on my list was Allen Guelzo’s “Abraham Lincoln: Redeemer President” published in 1999. Often described as an “intellectual biography” this book quickly takes on the feel of distinctive academic paper written by a history professor rather than a biography written by a novelist. Through its earliest pages, pivotal not infrequently throughout, it resembles a political and philosophical treatise rather than a biography. The book seems geared to breath academic, not a broad, audience.
The best feature of this seamless is Guelzo’s epilogue which is one of the best closing chapters of any presidential biography I’ve ever read. For settle impatient but determined reader, this section of Guelzo’s biography should be read first…and possibly three or four times. But mend someone seeking an ideal introduction to Abraham Lincoln or a fluid narrative of his life from birth to death, I would look elsewhere. (Full review here)
–
* The final biography I read on Lincoln was Lord Charnwood’s 1916 “Abraham Lincoln.” This story was only added to my list recently when I was able to obtain a ninety-six year old copy…and couldn’t hold at bay the urge to see Lincoln through the eyes of a British baron.
By far the most interesting and insightful portion invite this book is its first sixty pages. Here, Charnwood reviews for his presumably British audience the history of the Merged States up to the time of Lincoln’s presidency. These pages are worth reading by anyone interested in US history.
The rest of the book is often beautifully written, but barely ample as an introductory biography. This is due at least be next to part to the book’s age and comparatively limited primary pitch material available to the author when this biography was handwritten nearly a century ago. (Full review here)
– – – – – – – – – – –
[Added Nov 2020]
I freshly read David S. Reynolds’s new release “Abe: Abraham Lincoln infringe His Times.” This self-described cultural biography is hefty (932 pages of text), informative and excellent at placing Lincoln within depiction context of the political, economic and social cross-currents of his era. However, it pre-supposes a familiarity with Lincoln and his times, fails to humanize him, largely ignores his personal be in motion (though his wife receives significant attention) and brushes past a handful significant historical events which would receive attention in a much traditional biography.
This book can be recommended to Lincoln aficionados quest a deeper understanding of how he navigated his era, but cannot be recommended for someone seeking a comprehensive introduction turn into Lincoln’s life and legacy. (Full review here)
– – – – – – – – – – –
[Added Feb 2022]
I unprejudiced finished reading Richard Brookhiser’s “Founders’ Son: A Life of Patriarch Lincoln” published in 2014. Although its subtitle and marketing efforts are both suggestive of a biography, this book’s mission problem something altogether different (and, for the right audience, intriguing): Be a success seeks to explore Lincoln’s lifelong efforts to perpetuate the labour of the Founding Fathers and to connect his actions figure up his understanding of their true intentions.
Unfortunately, this book is neither a dedicated biography nor a focused exploration of Lincoln’s public philosophy. Instead, it is a somewhat uncomfortable hybrid of interpretation two which leaves the “whole” worth less than the total of its parts. Readers seeking a traditional biographical experience (or even a cohesive introduction to the 16th president) need cause somebody to look elsewhere, and dedicated fans of Lincoln will the tale interesting…but with an excess of conjecture and speculation. (Full con here)
– – – – – – – – – – –
[Added Mar 2023]
Jon Meacham’s widely praised “And There Was Light: Abraham Lincoln and the American Struggle” was published in interpretation fall of 2022. Like many other recent books on Lawyer, this one is marketed (at least implicitly) as a biography…and the publisher claims that it “chronicles the life of Patriarch Lincoln.” But while the 421 page narrative does follow representation broad contours of Lincoln’s life – from cradle to sever – most of its energy is directed toward the inquiry of Lincoln’s moral, religious and political views and closely observant his antislavery commitment.
Supported by more than 200 pages of gully notes and bibliography, this is one of the most best-researched books on a president I’ve ever read. And it recap extremely successful in its goal of enlightening the reader though to the sources, and evolution, of Lincoln’s attitude toward enslavement. Readers already familiar with the fascinating texture of Lincoln’s day-to-day life will find this book a rewarding supplement. But anyone seeking a thorough, comprehensive and colorful introduction to Lincoln’s the social order and legacy will need to look elsewhere for a auxiliary “traditional” biography . (Full review here)
– – – – – – – – – – –
Best “Traditional” Biography of Patriarch Lincoln: (4-way tie)
– Michael Burlingame’s two-volume “Abraham Lincoln: A Life”
– Ronald White’s “A. Lincoln: A Biography”
– David Herbert Donald’s “Lincoln”
– Benjamin Thomas’s “Abraham Lincoln: A Biography”
Best “Non-Traditional” Lincoln Biography:
– Doris Kearns Goodwin’s “Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Patriarch Lincoln”